The Fortress vs Brimfield Star: Which EPP Block to Choose
By Paper Pieces for English Paper Piecing | Published: 2026-10-20
Category: Comparisons
Compare The Fortress by Libs Elliott and Brimfield Star EPP templates to find the best quilt block for your project, based on seam allowance, complexity, and design style.
Quick answer
For a bold, geometric statement with a simple 1/4" seam allowance, choose The Fortress by Libs Elliott. If you prefer a classic star with flexible seam options and a complete set, go with Brimfield Star.
Design and complexity
The Fortress by Libs Elliott brings a modern, architectural feel to your quilt with its 2-piece acrylic template set. Its geometric design stands out in contemporary projects and works well as a focal block.
Brimfield Star offers a more traditional star motif, often used in Brimfield Awakening quilts. It may involve more pieces, making it a better fit for quilters who enjoy a bit more assembly challenge.
Seam allowance and format flexibility
The Fortress is designed with a fixed 1/4" seam allowance, which is standard for many EPP projects. This makes it straightforward if you're used to that allowance.
Brimfield Star gives you a choice: you can select 1/4" or 3/8" seam allowance, or even buy a complete set, pattern only, or single pieces. This flexibility is handy if you prefer larger seam allowances for thicker fabrics or need just one piece to replace a lost one.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Seam allowance flexibility: If you need a larger seam allowance for thicker fabrics or personal preference, Brimfield Star offers 3/8" option, while The Fortress is fixed at 1/4". Check your fabric thickness before choosing.
- Block complexity: The Fortress is a simple 2-piece set, ideal for beginners or quick projects. Brimfield Star may have more pieces, offering a more intricate look but requiring more time. Estimate your time and skill level.
- Purchase format: Brimfield Star can be bought as a complete set or individual pieces, which is great for replacements or customizing. The Fortress comes only as a 2-piece set. If you need only a single piece, choose Brimfield Star.
Product facts
- The Fortress by Libs Elliott: The Fortress by Libs Elliott is a 2-piece acrylic fabric cutting template set with a 1/4" seam allowance. The 2-piece set and standard seam allowance make it easy to cut and piece a bold, geometric block without extra adjustments.
The Fortress by Libs Elliott - BRIMFIELDSTAR: Brimfield Star is available in several options: 1/4" seam, 3/8" seam, complete, pattern only, and single. You can tailor the format to your project needs, whether you want a full set or just a replacement piece, and choose your preferred seam allowance.
BRIMFIELDSTAR
Which block fits you?
Best for
- Modern quilters who want a bold, geometric focal block with minimal pieces.
- Beginners looking for a simple 2-piece template with a standard seam allowance.
Not for
- Quilters who need a larger seam allowance or want to buy individual replacement pieces.
